People Stole
Our Flyers.

What everyone remembers—and forgets—about marketing The Blair Witch Project.

Everyone remembers the website.

What I remember is sitting on the floor making stick figures.

In 1999, I was SVP of Worldwide Marketing at Artisan Entertainment when we acquired The Blair Witch Project after Sundance. My area was field operations, promotions and partnerships, although we were such a lean team that everybody touched pretty much everything.

The marketing campaign has become its own kind of folklore. The story usually goes like this: we built a website, people found it, they thought the story was real, the movie went viral.

Except that leaves out most of the work.

People forget what the Internet was actually like in 1999. Nobody was sitting at home randomly typing movie URLs into a browser. There was no social media serving you things because you’d watched another horror trailer. No Instagram. No YouTube. No TikTok.

Nobody was just going to wake up one morning and type in blairwitch.com.

We had to give them a reason to go looking.

And I was fascinated by the thing from the beginning. Not just the movie. The whole world around it.

Elly Kedward. Coffin Rock. Rustin Parr. The missing children. Burkittsville. This history that seemed to stretch back generations before Heather, Mike and Josh ever walked into those woods.

There was always another layer.

Sometimes it was something the filmmakers had already created. Sometimes we’d get further into the mythology and find a hole and essentially say, okay, what happened here?

And then we’d make something up. But it had to belong.

What interested me wasn’t simply whether people would believe it was real. It was the feeling of finding it. That very human combination of curiosity and fear and wonder when you stumble onto something strange and need to know what comes next.

So we kept giving people things to find.

And a lot of it was incredibly unsexy.

Interns, a skeleton staff and I sat on the floor building those twig figures by hand. We mailed them to people. We left them places. We printed flyers and hired street teams to put them up in high-traffic areas. Basic, old-fashioned field marketing. Physical stuff in physical places intended to make somebody stop and think, what the hell is this?

Then people started stealing the flyers.

I don’t mean they were being removed because somebody objected to them. People were taking them.

We’d send the street teams back out and discover the flyers were gone. So we’d replace them. Then they’d disappear again. We had to keep repopulating locations.

I loved it.

Website traffic told us people were looking. A missing flyer told me somebody cared enough to take a piece of the story home.

At the same time, we were taking the mythology everywhere we could. I was making deals around books and comics. We developed an investigative-style dossier. Elly Kedward, Coffin Rock and Rustin Parr could have lives outside the movie. Even the soundtrack stayed inside the conceit: Josh’s Blair Witch Mix, supposedly recovered from Josh’s abandoned car.

These weren’t meant to be a stack of conventional movie tie-ins. Each one was another way into the story.

One of the first times I realized how far this might go was in a meeting at the Sci-Fi Channel.

I went with the filmmakers and we played Bonnie Hammer about a minute and a half of material we’d put together as a pitch for what eventually became Curse of the Blair Witch.

She got it immediately.

Here was someone outside our little group who immediately felt the pull of it. And she had a national television network.

Curse of the Blair Witch wasn’t a making-of special. That would have ruined the fun. It treated the mythology as history. Elly Kedward, Rustin Parr, the missing filmmakers, Burkittsville — they were presented as if all of this had actually happened and somebody had simply gone back and documented it.

We weren’t stepping outside the story to advertise the movie. We were adding another room to the house.

And the more rooms we added, the harder it became to make sure the whole thing held together.

There were characters and dates, murders and disappearances, different versions of stories, the website, television, publishing, physical artifacts. Eventually all of that had to be organized and cross-referenced in what we called the Blair Witch “Black Bible.”

I still love that.

Magic requires paperwork.

If Rustin Parr did something in one year on the website, you couldn’t have a book casually putting it in another year. If someone discovered one part of the history in a comic and another part somewhere else, they had to feel as though they belonged to the same world.

Someone had to keep track of all this shit.

And then the site really did start to blow up.

All this mythology we had been building piece by piece — flyers on walls, twig figures made on the floor, bits of history tucked into different places — suddenly had somewhere to travel that wasn’t dependent on us physically putting the next thing in front of somebody.

People were finding it. They were going deeper. And they were pulling other people in with them.

We had spent all this time creating the rabbit hole, and suddenly people were disappearing down it on their own.

But the website didn’t create the fascination. It gave the fascination somewhere to go.

I still look for the equivalent of those stolen flyers.

What I’m looking for is the moment when somebody stops simply receiving what we’re putting in front of them and starts doing something of their own accord.

They search for the film. They send something to somebody else. They buy the ticket. They bring another person into the story.

Those behaviors tell me something reach alone can’t.

Reach tells me what we did. I want to know what the audience did next.

That is a question I bring to the work at A Jones House. What are we giving people a reason to discover? What can they take into their own lives and pass along? And what are they actually doing with it?

The web eventually took The Blair Witch Project places none of us could possibly have reached by hand. But first we had to make people want to go looking.

More than twenty-five years later, I can still remember sending the street teams back out because someone had stolen the flyers again.

The campaign in practice

Explore the audience strategy and campaign work behind The Blair Witch Project.

Explore the Blair Witch case study
Getting People to Care

Adapted from my essay first published in Getting People to Care on October 19, 2026.

Read the original essay (opens in a new tab)

More on audiences, entertainment and what makes people act.

Read and subscribe on Substack (opens in a new tab)
Start a conversation.

Tell us about your project.

Tell us what you’re making, where it stands and what you need help with.

Start a conversation